xml/rss: http://feeds.feedburner.com/PoliticalRants

Thursday, November 18, 2004

The invalidity of the "Cultural values cost us the election" argument

All this talk about the cultural values of the President winning him the election has empowered and emboldened fragment Christian groups to all new levels. They are marching in Chicago with 10 foot high banners of dead babies, praying in DC outside Arlen Specter's office, on the news, on the radio, in print, on the Internet.

Fact is, they aren't the only ones who were voting their morals on November 2. Every Kerry supporter I have spoken with (and remember, I did canvassing, so that is a large number) cited cultural issues as a large reason for voting against Bush.

1) Woman's right to choose v. Christian beliefs
2) Homosexual marriages v. Christian beliefs
3) Killing babies in Iraq v. killing unborn American children
4) Extrajudicial killing v. due process
5) Putting criminals that hurt Americans behind bars, like Gary Winnick of Global Crossing, Ken Lay of Enron, Bernie Ebbers of World Com, and Dennis Kozlowski of Tyco v. Martha Stewart
6) Due process, right to council v. Illegal international war crimes detention in Guantanamo
7) Separation of church and state v. unification of Christian church and US policy
8) Admitting ones faults v. blindly insisting they have not made mistakes (doing God's work)
9) Fiscal responsibility v. tax cuts in the face of record deficits

These are all beliefs held by the 49% that did not vote for "Cultural Values" and "Moral Issues" ... these all are cultural values and moral issues as well. Just not the ones of central, ignorant Americana. With all the noise the news has made about how people chose Bush as the moral leader, little has been said about the 49% that chose against bush as the moral leader.

Wake up Americana. You are left behind.

2 Comments:

Blogger obscurity said...

Agreed whole heartedly. I would say your arguement supports my assertion. My assertion is that this noise about "Moral Values" which the media claims won Bush the http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory?id=224618 re-election is a bunch of hooey. That http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2004/11/03/politics/main653238.shtml 22% that voted for Bush ... is far outweighed by people, in that same article, 26% support gay marriage, and still 1-in-3 people firmly against gay marriage supported Kerry.

I just don't want the media to play up this "Moral Values" card as much as they have ... because it makes the Democrats ... want to take on religion as a plank in their platform. And the Democrats cannot beat Republicans by trying to emulate them. Honestly, the Republicans are much better at being Republicans than the Democrats are.

7:29 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I appreciate your recognition of "fragment Christian groups" but the rest of you comment seems to lump all Christians together. The list of generalizations in your A v. B list (or should I write A v. Christian beliefs list?) paints the picture with too broad a brush.

That lack of clarity misses the mark. I voted "against Bush" in the election and wish I had been convinced to vote "for" a great candidate. The Republicans did a far better job mobilizing segments of the Christian right and the Democrats. No one did a great job mobilizing the moderate Christians. Spending part of the next four years understanding issues of faith may make a big difference in 2008. Understanding issues of faith in the Middle East could make a big difference in peace in that region.

6:26 PM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home